Visiting Dufftown’s Ghost Distillery: Convalmore
Drinking a Convalmore is something I have done probably less than ten times in my whisky life span of over 20 years. The distillery has been closed since 1985 and independent and official releases have been sparse. There have been three (spectacular) official releases in the Special Releases series by Diageo, and only one in the Rare Malts Selection. There were also two even more unobtainable releases in what I call the Sheiks & Oligarch series that Diageo ran, but those are not intended for consumption so let’s ignore them. With this in mind, some 130 releases big and small remain, and we taste one today that was bottled by Gordon & MacPhail. But first, let us have a look at the history of Convalmore Distillery.

Convalmore is a very relevant distillery, as it was the fourth distillery built in Dufftown, a little hamlet that would ultimately house seven “stills”. With neighbours like Glenfiddich, Balvenie and Mortlach, Convalmore was always in good company. It was also a product of the optimistic but in the end economic bubble of the late Victorian period. Ulf Buxrud in his standard work about the Rare Malts Selection mentions a specific date for the establishment of the company that would erect Convalmore: 23 June 1893.
Full production started in February 1894. Soon after, the struggles began to keep head above water, and in the aftermath of the Pattison Crash, Convalmore went into liquidation in 1904. Mr. W.P. Lowrie took over, having himself experience as distillery manager of Port Ellen on Islay. He was a whisky broker since 1869, and Convalmore was already firmly in hands of Glaswegian brokers anyway. Seemed like a good fit then. Financial hardships endured however, and Convalmore ended up in the hands of James Buchanan, thus establishing a connection with the Black & White blend. Put on top of that a devastating fire on 29 October 1909, and we can safely say that Convalmore had a shaky first 15 years of existence!
From 1910 onwards, business seemed to be looking bright. Convalmore was rebuilt and the owner started experimenting with continuous malt distilling. That was no success, according to reports I could find. The Coffey still was removed in 1915 already. In 1925 Convalmore fell into the hands of DCL (forefather of Diageo) and again shaky times happened, with dormancy in the Second World War included. Incredibly, in the 1960s optimism was up again and Convalmore even got an expansion with new pot stills, extra warehousing and the arrival of a dark grains plant. In 1975 a new mash house was opened.



The 1980s saw a lot of distilleries go silent, and Convalmore was among them. However, this closure was much less permanent compared to, say, Dallas Dhu or Coleburn. It also came a little later, only in 1985, so it is not weird if you run into a 1984 vintage in a bottle. Convalmore was initially mothballed, but eventually the stills would stay silent anyway. Glenfiddich actually bought the entire site and everything on it, and mostly uses the space for maturation purposes. True or not, but that Convalmore should remain a lost distillery was probably part of the deal between Diageo and William Grants & Sons. With space for no less than 17.000 casks, it is easy to understand why Glenfiddich wanted this deal.
In recent times, old stills like Rosebank, Brora and Port Ellen started producing again, but Convalmore was never part of the chatter. Chatter you can also hear around the names of Dallas Dhu and Coleburn. It seems that Convalmore will be forever lost. During one night of my visit to Speyside in 2011, my dear whisky pal Fulco Bakker and I walked the grounds. An eerily environment, breathing the air of long lost souls. Fulco managed to dig up some pictures from his extensive archive, added to the blog today.
Photography: Fulco Bakker – thank you!

Convalmore 1960, Rare Old, bottled at 40 % abv by Gordon & MacPhail
First things first: Bottled in 2002, this release comes with little more information than that. We calculate that this is at least 41 years old, and pour the sample in the glass.
Upon Sipping: Let us see if the 40 % abv has survived after almost 25 years in the bottle. On the nose, I am immediately reassured that the whisky is good, and even typical for Convalmore. I always associate the malt with a minty aroma, and this 1960 vintage opens on that as well. Mint Julep actually, mixed with soft streaks of banana and malty notes. Some gummi bears also made their way into the glass. Luxury whisky that you can sniff a whole evening long. The low abv obviously does not challenge the nostrils, so you can really put your nose into it and enjoy. With more time, grassy notes take a more pronounced stand. The imprint of 40 years in the cask seems modest, the spirit is very much alive.
On the palate, we start suffering however. The wood is very pronounced in contrast to the nose. It hid itself among the aroma on the nose, but the palate is totally dominated by it. Dry oak, or the sensation of licking a pencil, which I am sure many of us did in high school when we were bored, looking out the window at the falling leaves of Autumn. In a way, the taste has something nostalgic, even if it is overrun. The finish has a good kick, which makes the taste linger for a long time.
Despite the low abv, I tried adding just a wee drop of water, to refresh it. The nose offers more fruit now. It is all old and past its expiry date, but fruit nonetheless. Some old oranges left on the bowl too long, in the sun in front of your kitchen window. Some waxes now too. It suddenly became an old style malt that we love so much. A touch or koriander enters the field. The palate has not improved. With some imagination you could find old, hardened honey in this, but the wood elements are just too loud. We have to respect 41 or 42 years in the cask, but it was probably ten years too long. Still, slainte!
Word to the Wise: This Convalmore presents itself admirably on the nose, but suffers from the conditions with which it was put into the bottle. It is deliciously old style, with some flaws we can overlook considering this is a Convalmore from 1960. Unique whisky.
Score: 86 points.

