A closer look at Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey
Thanks to a generous share by my dear whisk(e)y friend Robbert, today I will taste through a range of Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey. It is a category that in general produces a light and fruity style whiskey, which I enjoy a lot. With our final sample, the Redbreast, there is no doubt about its provenance. Consumers should however be careful when they buy a product from the other two Irish distilleries we are going to taste, as they release multiple variants. Those could be a blend for instance, and not necessarily a Single Pot Still.
Irish Pot Still Whiskey is a distinctive style made from a mash of both malted and unmalted barley. It is distilled in copper pot stills and matured in wooden casks in Ireland for at least three years. The raw, unmalted barley gives the spirit its creamy, oily texture and signature spicy, peppery character, almost like a hybrid form of single malt and single grain whiskey. The style took shape in the 18th century, when high taxes on malt pushed distillers toward cheaper raw barley. After nearly vanishing in the 20th century, it has enjoyed a revival, with Redbreast among its most celebrated ambassadors. It is also a protected geographical indication, so it must be produced on the island of Ireland to carry the name.

Clonakilty Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey, bottled at 46 % abv
First things first: Clonakilty named itself the Atlantic Distillery, and indeed did the casks mature near the ocean. Made out of 100 % Irish barley, the triple distilled whiskey matured in bourbon, oloroso and Amontillado casks. There is no age statement.
Upon Sipping: This is nice and fresh with a hint of tropical fruits but nothing too frontal. The oloroso and Amontillado seem to be modestly used, which is a good thing if the whole point of the bottling is the Single Pot Still concept. Besides the fruit some yellow candy gummi bears and maybe a whiff of something salty. Could be the power of suggestion. Taking a sip, the candylike sweetness is a (trick or) treat! Tasting this mere days after Halloween makes it a pleasure. Ask your dentist how to brush after drinking such a sugary dram! The mouthfeel is much more complex and mature than expected, adding depth to this bottling. With water, some energy is added, but the whiskey stays more or less the same. It does flush away a hint of bitterness on the finish that did not sit well with me undiluted.
Word to the Wise: This Clonakilty ticks all the boxes on what a Single Pot Still Irish should be. My only complaint is that it is perhaps still a bit immature, but the potential is there. This will be a killer bottle at 10 or 12 years.
Score: 82 points.

Clonakilty Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey, bottled at 53 % abv for Craft Spirits
First things first: This Clonakilty was finished in a Calem Porto Tawny Port Pipe. It is a single cask with # 9465 and produced 914 bottles. Bottled for Craft Spirits for the Dutch market. There is no age statement.
Upon Sipping: With its dark colour, it is no surprise the port influence is loud. Also a bit cloaking the character we could pick up in the more balanced bottling above. Wet wood, red fruits, and some dustiness on an old cabinet in the attic. The red fruit becomes more apparent after some time in the glass. The palate carries a lot of spices but then it turns very dry and rubbery. The bitter chocolate notes, if I can call it that, are there but it turns into tired wood soon enough. With water, the nose improves as it opens up even more on red fruit notes like wild strawberry and overripe cherries. The taste remains too bitter for my preference and the wood spices from the port pipe are very invasive. I do not think that this finish was a smart plan, unless you like this overpowered wine influences in your whiskey.
Word to the Wise: It is a bit puzzling. You take the most delicate style of whiskey, made with a portion of raw material, AND triple distilled, and then expose it to an aggressive fortified wine element. It is like putting an introverted child next to your loudest uncle on a birthday. Nobody has a good time. Try before you buy, but this stuff seems aimed at dark colour whiskey fetishists, IMHO.
Score: 78 points.

Busker Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey, bottled at 46,3 % abv
First things first: Small batch no. 1 was matured in bourbon and oloroso casks. A product from the Royal Oak Distillery.
Upon Sipping: Oh my, this is quite a contrast with the Clonakilty expressions. Much fruitier and strong on these little jars of baby food in the supermarket. A nice potpourri of all kinds of things from the fruit bowl, but more to the expressive side. Tangerine, oranges, peaches, passion fruit, red apples. This all seems to mingle well with a nice wood spice from the oloroso side of things. On the palate, the stewed fruits return, they were not just an empty promise on the nose then! That is definitely encouraging. It has some raw edges though, this must still be young, but there is so much promise. The finish is warming on wood spices, with just a sliver of tobacco. I am impressed with the balance. With water, it feels a bit fragile, but just like the Clonakilty it is easy to imagine this will blow us away with a few years more in the cask.
Word to the Wise: The nose on this Busker Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey is most impressive. The rest of the experience has a high standard to live up to but struggles. Probably because of some immaturity. But this will be a stunning product with a few more years of ageing.
Score: 84 points.

Redbreast Lustau Edition, bottled at 46 % abv
First things first: The same principle as the Busker above, with an initial bourbon maturation and then a finish in first fill oloroso sherry. An expression from after the rebranding in 2019.
Upon Sipping: The proud standard bearer of Single Pot Still Irish whiskey made at the Midleton Distillery that creates like a million different variants of Irish whiskey, not in the least Jameson. But this Redbreast carries more weight than that. The nose is nowhere near as fruity as the Busker, but it carries gravitas nonetheless. Caramel, raisins and rum, stewed apples and pears, dusty clothes in an old forgotten cabinet. More complex, but less flashy. The palate also leans close to the more bitter notes infused by the sherry, resulting in a fruity raisin mix, coupled with milk chocolate and sweet barley. This Redbreast Lustau feels closer connected to the Clonakilty, which makes a nice full circle for this blog. I expected some more fireworks, but it is all decent enough to warrant a positive mark. With water, we call out some ginger bread and Christmas cake. The spices have deepened and leave a nice, wood infused tingle on the tongue when you swallow. The finish brings a hint of strawberry chocolate and apricot essence.
Word to the Wise: Balance, muscle and confidence is what this Redbreast Lustau Edition brings to the table, especially when compared to “cairde” in the same category. The youngsters have some homework, but all in all we had a great session here!
Score: 85 points.

